Leather Wrist Band problems I need your help

In 10 days I will be celebrating my 2 year anniversary with my boyfriend, Adam. I bought a set of matching leather wrist bands that I had personalized but there is a slight issue. Mine is too big length wise. It would not be a problem if the wrist bands weren't wide, but they have to be 2 inches wide to fit the whole date on them. So my question for you is how to effectively and quickly shrink the wrist band ( already tried water and the dryer and just letting it sit) or what to use to make it smaller ( like an extra snap) That is easy and effective. It has a set of heavy duty snaps on it which is why it's too big, if it was like a belt or Velcro it would be ok. Any advice my fellow bloggers?